Higher Education Must Strive to Connect Hearts and Minds
By Diana Chapman Walsh Wellesley College | March 11, 2007
Last month, a group of over 600 educators from 260 colleges, universities and other organizations met in San Francisco for a conference entitled "Uncovering the Heart of Higher Education: Integrative Learning for Compassionate Action in an Interconnected World." Sponsored by the Fetzer Institute and the California Institute of Integral Studies, the meeting is described on a website with the url: www.heartofeducation.org.
The conference brought together a wide range of voices from many different perspectives: faculty from across the curriculum, student life professionals, chaplains, deans and provosts, presidents and vice presidents, students, young alumnae, community activists, clergy, administrators across the spectrum. These were educators who are forging vital connections between religion, peace, contemplation, justice, ecology, dialogue, diversity, service, community, vocation, spirituality, forgiveness, love – a mighty river flowing to a destination that's still uncertain.
The call to the conference tapped something very deep, a yearning and a hunger in the many hundreds who made their way to San Francisco, and the many thousands more they serve or represent. The speakers' roster included a number of people who have been working for years to challenge institutions of higher learning to think more broadly about their missions. The keynote addresses are available on CDs which can be purchased through the website.
The backdrop for this gathering was – and is – the disturbing reality that the world we are passing on to future generations is far more fragile than we imagined it might be – even a mere decade ago. Intense and sobering questions daily press on our awareness now in new and alarming forms: environmental degradation, nuclear proliferation, absolute poverty and a terrible gap between rich and poor, wars in the name of the sacred all around the globe, and here at home, the erosion of vital boundaries between church and state, and a military-industrial complex that has run amok. The recent shift in political tides in the United States has, if anything, brought into sharper focus how far we have wandered, as a people and a nation hell-bent on accumulating wealth, from a core commitment to the mutual obligations that a generous reading of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" was intended to stir.
Many participants argued - cogently and on a variety of grounds – for reforms to our educational system that would encourage much more powerful connections between head and heart, theory and action, privilege and service. Many interesting and promising models were described and discussed. But I haven't been able to shake one brief interchange I heard at a plenary session. A young philosophy professor described in vivid detail the tactics evangelical groups at her university are using to "prey on" incoming first year students who are lonely and vulnerable and to convince them not to believe anything their professors are teaching them.
I came away from this meeting more convinced than ever that we must not allow this "Whatever..." generation to graduate from college perfectly content to accept that all belief systems are equally valid and true. The stakes are too high, especially now. If we leave them unable to know their own minds and hearts, they will stand helpless in a market economy hawking selfish materialism, and hopeless in a world of fundamentalisms -- dangerous shortcuts to the coherence and the meaning that we failed to help them find for themselves while they were in college.
March 11, 2007 |Tags: education, education reform, higher education | TrackBack


Posted by: Billy Shore on March 12, 2007 at 8:16 AM
Diana, I read your article about connecting hearts and minds with much interest and applaud the concerns you raise. In part what you seem to be talking about is compassion. I am not sure that academic settings are instituted to teach compassion and matters of the heart although this may be highly debatable. Most churches don't even address compassion issues particularly around economic disparity, and race relations but rather concentrate on personal success-materialism. In today's Los Angeles Times there is an op-ed piece sparked by Forbes 400 index of billionaires. The headline for this piece reads "A wealth of cheapskates" that accurately describes the essence of the story. The reason I mention this is that wealth has always been, in my six plus decades on earth, a fundamental American value. Getting as much as one can is an acceptable and cherished goal. Compassion or sharing, on the other hand, has always been in the back seat if not the trunk. Connecting heart and mind and producing compassion and sharing wealth is a complicated issue. Where does compassion come from?Can a university teach compassion? In my case, any level of compassion I may have in my heart(mind)was aroused by my compassionate grandfather when I was very young back in the late 1940's. His example influenced me. Much of the work I have engaged in my adult life was driven by compassion and not money. The reason I can say this with confidence is that I believe the primary goal of a human being is to be compassionate and especially toward the majority of the people in the world who struggle to survive. In my own belief system, Christianity, the core message of the founder is compassion. As for the "whatever" generation Bob Dylan sang a song that said something like"if you don't believe in something, you will fall for anything." Finally, for those of the Christian perspective, relying on money and not compassion (love) for others will be your fall.
Posted by: Jim Hubbard on March 18, 2007 at 2:14 PM
Post a comment
© Copyright 2006 Sharing Witness. All rights reserved.


I wonder if there are any international equivalents to the conference Diana Chapman Walsh describes. The "world of fundamentalisms" seems even more pronounced outside the U.S. and the very important work she helps lead in encouraging more powerful connections between head and heart would be invaluable in so many additional venues beyond our borders as well.